Time is August 8th, 2016 at 8 pm. The next day, Yang Yue was found dead in a well in the village. The public security authorities decided that they had died of drowning and decided not to file the case.
The two are villagers in Guozhuang Village, a civil rights county in Shangqiu, Henan Province. Yang Yue’s parents, Yang Yanhua and Lu Zhengying, believed that the death of his son had a direct relationship with Yang Junqi and he sued him to the court and demanded compensation of 100,000 yuan.
On February 20, 2017, the civil rights county court dismissed the two claims. Afterwards, the two appealed to the Shangqiu Intermediate People's Court. On July 22, 2017, when neither party provided new evidence and materials, the court decided that Yang Junqi would compensate the family members of the deceased with a total of 100,000 yuan in losses.
When interviewed by the Responsible Crime Team No. 37 (WeChat ID: zhonganzu37), Yang Yue's parents said that if Yang Junqi did not “organize people to scare people”, the son would never die; Yang Junqi denied “scaring” each other. He thinks he is not wrong and will not recompense. "I criticized his starting point is also good, did not expect to cause such consequences."
Full text 3277 words, reading about 6 minutes
▲Location of the incident. Map/Cover News
Juvenile Overpass Critical Education
Yang YanhuaThe direct cause of the death of Yang Yue, the son, was that Yang Junqi “organized people to scare him”. "After the morning the son was scared, he didn't go home again." He told the Crimes Unit 37 (WeChat ID: Zhonganzu 37).
"Same day" refers to August 27, 2016. According to the first-instance judgment of the Civil Rights County Court, the 14-year-old Yang Yue was discovered by Yang Junqi and other villagers in the process of overturning the villager Yang Heyi and was criticized and educated.
The next morning, Yang Yue was found dead in a well in the village. Yang Yue’s mother, Lu Zhengying, warned that his son was suspected of being killed. After the forensic identification and investigation of the Civil Rights Bureau Public Security Bureau, Yang Yue died of drowning before entering the water. The public security agency decided not to file the case.
According to media reports, several villagers who witnessed the criticism process have testified that Yang Junqi did not insult him and found no physical contact during the process of discovering Yang Yue’s jumping on the wall and criticizing and educating him. . However, Yang Yue’s parents insist that Yang Junqi should be responsible for the child’s death.
Yang Yanhua and Lu Zhengying alleged that Yang Junqi discovered that Yang Yue organized a number of people to use verbal intimidation and other methods to “shelve for nearly half an hour.” "Thinking that Yang Junqi's behavior has caused Yang Yue's death, he should compensate the families of the deceased with 100,000 yuan in funeral expenses, death compensation, and spiritual soothing payments."
Yang Junqi said that he has not organized anyone to threaten Yang Yue. There is no causal relationship between Yang Yue’s death and his behavior.
Critics were awarded 100,000 yuan
The Minquan County Court held that the family of the deceased could not provide sufficient and valid evidence to prove that Yang Junqi was at fault for the death of Yang Yue. The decision rejected the two's claims.
The Minquan County Court of First Instance verdict stated that Yang Junqi could not be proved There is fault in the death of Yang Yue.
On July 20, 2017, Shangqiu City Intermediate People's Court made a judgment. The court held that Yang Yue jumped into the wall and jumped into the villager Yang Heyi without a reason. There was improper behavior. However, after Yang Junqi caught Yang Yue, he criticized education for nearly half an hour, which may have pressure and influence on the minds of minors. After Yang Junqi knew that Yang Yue was the son of Yang Yanhua, a villager, he did not communicate with his parents in a timely manner. He had more education and inadequate protection.
▲The court of second instance adjudicates that Yang Junqi assumes 40% liability and compensation 100,000 yuan. P>
"As a minor, in so many people in the crowd, by verbal stimulation, the pressure is very large, exceeding minors bottom-line ...... If there is not a foreign misconduct incentives, it is difficult to imagine A juvenile walked alone in the deep well in the corn groves to seek death." The court of second instance found that the death of the victim had a lot to do with the stimulation of Yang Junqi. Yang Junqi should bear the responsibility for compensation and sentenced him to compensate the family of the deceased with 100,000 yuan.
Because the compensation was not fulfilled, Yang Junqi was included in the list of defaulters by the court and became Lao Lai. He said they were not at fault, should not bear liability, is continuing to appeal.
▲Yang Junqi was listed as Lao Lai due to failure to perform compensation.
"No severe blaming him"
Crime Unit No. 37: Do you know how Yang Yue turned into cousin's house?
Yangjun Qi: strong> that morning around 8:00, I feed the chickens at a chicken farm about 300 meters away. The wife came to call me to go home for dinner. When she passed my cousin Yang and Yijia, she found that someone had turned in from the wall and told me about it.
Heavy Case No. 37: After hearing this news, what was your first reaction?
Yang Junqi: I think it must be a thief. During that time, the village often lost things. In the previous month or two, some families were smashed and 20,000 yuan were stolen. A few days ago, an old man lost his radio at home. I thought at the time if the thief returned to steal something. Just a few people were chatting near the chicken farm and we passed together.
Yang Junqi: A villager went with me and came to the scene in about four or five minutes. Then five or six people came along.
After I got outside the room, I heard that someone was pushing the door of the house. He might have heard our footsteps and he would not push it. Then I went to a nearby highland and wanted to see what he was doing. As soon as he stood there, he flipped out of the wall.
Yang Junqi: He looks like an adult. He's not too low. He wears glasses. I did not know him. The first reaction was to come from other villages to steal things. After seeing us, he did not say anything, and he hurried to go in the opposite direction.
Heavy team No. 37: How did you do it?
Yang Junqi: He was four or five meters away from me. I followed him and called him. He stood there. Later, several of us asked him what to do at someone's home? No one at home knows it? Which village is it?
We also said to him, "Don't jump to other people's homes later. If someone else has lost something at home and lost money, won't you?"
He supported me I said that it was the people in the village. "Nothing to do, jump to the yard and get something to play with." Then I asked his dad's name. After he said it, we all knew it. We didn't say anything more. Then he moved toward the country. Walking in the direction of the home.
Yang Junqi:No, no loud noises. Just said two words, he said what his father called. Because of his knowledge, he was not severely accused, and several other people did not say it.
Trong> Heavy Case No. 37: What was Yang Yue's response at that time? I nodded and said I knew. In the end he said something and never jumped to someone else's house. The voice was a bit weary and felt a little embarrassed. When he was gone, he was normal and he did not have any reaction to embarrassment or blush.
"I did not expect the child to die"
Heavy case group number 37: Did Yang Yue disappear the same day?
Yang Junqi:He didn't go home when he was eating that morning. At 8 or 9 in the evening, his mother came to the chicken farm and asked me to say that the child had never returned home. Let me help you find one. Later, we took separate actions. I found a lap in the village and went to the cafe in the town to find it. I did not find it until 1 a.m. in the morning.
Yang Junqi: That's not. Our village is very harmonious. Someone has something to do. Everyone will help. At that time his mother came to visit me and hoped that I could help me find it. I went straight to it.
Yang Junqi: My wife used to work in a place with her baby mom. The relationship is usually very good. I was also out of good intentions before I said this to her. Considering that the child is in junior high school, he will immediately go to the exam. If this happens to the police station, he or she may be afraid of affecting the child.
When did you find that Yang Yue died?
Yang Junqi: At 7 or 8 in the morning of the next morning, some villagers found the clothes of the children at the well of the ground and let his mother recognize them. They found that the clothes were those of Yang Yue. Several of us began to salvage, after which the children’s family members called the police. It was not until the afternoon that the children were dead.
Yang Junqi: Strongly sympathetic, I did not expect him to do this.
Yang Junqi:No, no one can prove his deathDeath and me are related. If I had just finished speaking, he would immediately jump into a well and die, and I could not escape this responsibility. But since I criticized him for his death, what happened during this period of time? Or is there any other stimulus? This is not yet known.
"I was surprised to learn that the court decided to pay compensation."
Heavy case group No. 37: After the incident the village party secretary came to mediate?
Yang Junqi: The family of the deceased asked me to get a funeral fee of 35,000. The village party secretary said this. I thought at the time that this was not my responsibility at all and there was no agreement. Without successful mediation, the family of the deceased told me.
When did you receive court subpoena
Yang Junqi: Received more than one month after the incident. At that time, I was very angry. I felt that it was a good thing that I was clearly doing. How did it become such a result? The incident to the first instance, a month I lost 17 pounds. After this incident happened, my family and I were under great pressure.
The judgment of the court did not allow me to pay compensation. I breathed a sigh of relief at once. After that, their family appealed again. In the absence of new evidence, the court judged that I would pay 100,000 yuan in the second instance.
Yang Junqi: It was surprising that the court decided that I need to bear 40% of the responsibility. I don't know how this figure came from. When I got this verdict, my heart was cold. The evidence and materials are the same as the first instance. Why is the judgment different?
I still feel that the starting point for this (criticizing Yang Yue) is good, but I did not expect to bear such a result. I feel very sad. At that time, I did not expect this to happen.
You have no compensation at all
Yang Junqi: At the beginning, when my family let me lose money, I did not pay. I think that it is my fault that I will bear. It is not my responsibility. I will definitely not make compensation and will continue to complain.
Yang Junqi: Alarm first, then criticize and educate him.
New Beijing News reporter Zhao Kaidi's intern Lu Gongjing
Editor Cao Linhua, Li Yujin, and Jin Li, Li Xiaoqin
This article isHeavy case Group 37 (WeChat ID: zhonganzu37) Original Content